Submission to Productivity Commission on Workplace Relations

By admin . On 20-Mar-2015

Inquiry into the Workplace Relations Framework

A response from the Council of Small Business Organisations of Australia

One of the great concerns for the small business community is the cost of employing people, not just in in time and money but also in increased levels of personal stress for the employer.

In small business the employer is very rarely an expert on workplace relations.  Yet they are expected to be an expert in this area as well as an expert on workplace health and safety, insurance, workers compensation, leasing requirements, competition law and the list goes on.

Almost 90% or workplaces in Australia employ less than 20 people and over 60% employ less than 5 people.  In 2012 that was almost 750,000 employing businesses, each run by a person or perhaps a couple.

Yet the workplace relations system is and always has been designed for paymasters, boards of directors and CEOs in the 10% of business – the largest businesses.

In the end the result of a confusing and expensive workplace relations is a negative impact on innovation, productivity and the economy.  It is also a reluctance by small business people to employ or to grow their business to employ more people.

The current system is designed by experts for experts. The current system is also designed by ideologues to suit their ideology not reality.

The workplace relations framework is one designed by “the IR club” to suit their needs and beliefs not the reality of the modern workplace.  It seems that there are two sides, the left and the right, and they take turns being in a position of influence and deciding on what WPR looks like; or being in the position of little influence, where they get to attack the other side.  They swap places at elections but the silliness continues and the pay clerks and experts deal with the changes as best they can while small business people are just confused.  The left and right of WPR also tend to fight among themselves in public and private spats that do not help foster confidence in the system.

Work Choices and Fair Work are or were systems based on outmoded beliefs about the way the workplace should operate and behave. Big business or big unions were heavily involved in developing both these systems.  They were designed by experts for experts.  They continue to cause angst for the left and right of the IR club

We need to change this paradigm of influence. We need a system designed for the reality of the many not for the fears and beliefs of a few.

An Industrial Award for the Small Workplace
COSBOA knows that any successful workplace relations system will need to be designed for the small workplace. But if big business and big unions want to maintain complexity (for their experts to argue about) then maybe we could have a workplace industrial award just for small business?  An award that is an option for any business that employs less than 20 people.

This award will have guaranteed rates of pay with simple descriptions of conditions, rights and responsibilities of the employer and the employee spelled out.

Employers and employees who are not experts, will then feel confident that they are paying and receiving the right pay. The current situation is too confusing and creates mistakes and conflict.

A real life example of the complex award system making trouble involves a small business owner who runs a convenience store.  He sells groceries and take-away food.  The award he is using covers all the workers in his shop.

One day he notices that many elderly people from a nearby aged care facility buy take away coffee and food from his shop and they have to stand around waiting for their order to be made. He provides a table and some chairs for the people to use while they are waiting.

Normally the customer would collect the food and coffee from the counter after their name is called out.  This was until one of the employees started to take the order out to the older people.  She does this out of the goodness of her heart as we should do for the older people in our community. All is good.  Everyone is happy.

Then the employee leaves and in a conversation with a friend is told that she should have been paid more money as she was actually serving food to a table.  She approaches the government workplace agency that forces the employer to pay many thousands of dollars of back pay.

This is of course ridiculous.  The employer and the employee were both behaving like well-meaning caring human beings.  The employer has now removed the offending table and chairs.  The outcome is not good for the older customers, for the community or the employer.

A single award for this shop would mean that no matter what the employee does that the pay stays the same.  No ambiguity, no fear of getting something wrong. No conflict. No opportunity for trouble makers to make trouble.  No need for an expensive and complicated enterprise agreement.

Under this proposal the minimum rates of pay for any employee in a small business would be the same and would not differ between businesses or industry sectors.

An employer can always pay above the rates of pay in the small business award.

It is a new idea, a workplace relations system based on size not on industry; it will worry people, especially those in the “IR Club”.  Now is the time to take complexity out of workplace relations and add certainty and flexibility.  A small business award for the majority will work once the minority, “the IR Clubbers”, are dismissed from the debate.

The Regulator and Legislative Framework

Currently there are three players in the WPR space: the Fair Work Commission (FWC); the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO); and the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC).

The FWC makes the rules under broad direction of Parliament.  The FWC also regulates disputes, bullying and unfair dismissal claims.

The FWO regulates employers on other issues and provides information as best it can on wages and conditions.

The AHRC takes complaints about sexual harassment and discrimination and deals with them in their own system.

This means there are three websites, three organisations and three sets of processes and procedures that exists for employers and employees.

We need to change that to become more streamlined and less confusing.  If there is a problem in the workplace there should be one website and one process that assists in resolving the issues.  Too much time is spent trying to work out who to contact.

Selection of FWA Commissioners
The selection process for commissioners to the FWA needs to become much more transparent and much more competitive.  Currently it appears that commissioners are selected by the government of the day based on advice from members of the IR club.  There is also little information on the current commissioners to assist in determining which ideology they will favour when making a decision in a complicated issue.  These commissioners will of course follow the law but whether we like it or not their ideology will have an influence somewhere.

Penalty rates
We believe in penalty rates as they have their place for those who work long hours or in different conditions but a community where a pharmacy has to close on Sundays is one that is not as healthy as it should be.  A community where school kids don’t get to earn extra money and learn about working life in weekend jobs is one where a complete education is not available to the next generation.  A community where service stations have to close on Sundays and do not open past 9pm at night due to penalty rates is not a complete community.

The penalty rates are too high and the times when penalty rates become available are complicated and differ from industry to industry.

We believe that penalty rates should not exceed time and a half and should be applied consistently across sectors.

Minimum hours of work
The current situation where an employee has a minimum time of 3 hours or where the employer has to seek approval to employ a school student for less than three hours is not reflective of the real world.  By all means if an employer is obviously abusing employees time by demanding long travel times for short periods of work where the cost of getting to work makes the time spent at work not rewarding then fix that problem.  Let the employee contact the regulator and have them sort that out.

But if a small business employs a school student after school for a short time than it is obvious this is acceptable and there should be no need to seek approval.

A minimum of one hour for people under 20 years of age who are in full time education should be a simple enough rule for employers.

There is no proof that many employers abuse the system, the workload for the regulator would be minimal.

The minimum wage
COSBOA believes there should be a minimum wage.  The removal of a minimum wage would create too much hostility and create uncertainty for employees.

The future framework
COSBOA recommends a framework based on the needs and capacity of the small workplace, this would involve:

Simplicity for ease of understanding for employers and employees

Transparency so that is obvious what a clause is meant to do

Highlighting the need and importance of a fair days pay for a fair days work

Recognition that a business must be viable to employ people and that viability is based on the capacity for the business owner to also make a fair living for his or her effort, and a return on the investment in the business and a return and reward for the risk taken.

One regulator with easy to use systems and easily accessed and understood communications processes

There are other issues that are not given enough consideration.  For example workplace relations processes is having an effect on competition in the retail sector.

Currently Coles and Woolworths are the biggest employers in Australia and the Shop Distributive and Allied Employees’ Association (SDA) is the biggest union in Australia.

The SDA has over 90% of its members in Coles and Woolworths.  Interestingly the SDA led the call for high penalty rates on Sundays, successfully having a national wide penalty rate of double time implemented.  Then the SDA negotiated an enterprise agreement with its associated large employers which provided a rate of time and half on Sundays.

The outcome of this is that small businesses close on Sundays and other days when penalty rates are high.  The large business do not close as their costs are lower on those days.  The large businesses get a bigger share of the market and the SDA gets more members.  That is an outcome that should not have occurred under a fair workplace relations system.

About the author


  • Change management, employment, the economy and local communities – bring back the CES

    31-Oct We have a national crisis with issues associated with skills and employment.  This includes apprent
  • We have a plan – an energy plan.

    18-Oct COSBOA has welcomed the “Powering Forward” energy plan announced by the government yesterday.
  • State Governments Must Act on Energy Prices to Avoid Economic Crisis

    15-Aug Now we have had time to discuss our national energy price crisis, it’s time to take action. State
  • 2017 Vodafone National Small Business Summit – Registrations Open

    19-May Registrations have now opened for the Vodafone National Small Business Summit, in Melbourne on 23 to
  • COSBOA Communique – Fair & Compliant Workplaces

    04-Apr COSBOA Communique - Fair & Compliant Workplaces On Monday 3 April 2017, COSB
  • Efficiency and Fairness in Workplace Relations Getting Closer

    24-Mar COSBOA today congratulated the government and the Industrial Relations Minister Senator Michaelia Ca
  • Penalty Rate Decision Provides Balance for Small Business on Sundays

    23-Feb COSBOA is pleased to see the creation of equity for employees and employers on Sundays with today’
  • Industry Groups Warn Telco Skills Crisis is Worsening

    09-Feb Communications Day publication recently interviewed Dominic Schipano from member as
  • Submission to Productivity Commission

    27-Jan The Council for Small Business Australia (COSBOA) recently made a submission to the Productivity Com
  • COSBOA Budget Priorities Statement

    23-Jan The Council of Small Business Australia (COSBOA) has released it's Priorities Statement for the 2017
  • Submission to Senate Inquiry

    13-Jan The Council of Small Business Australia recently made a submission to the Senate Economics Legislat
  • We thank you 2016 and welcome 2017 with hope and some fear.

    18-Dec There is no doubt 2016,
  • Superannuation payment system needs fixing – employers not the problem

    05-Dec The Australian Government must rethink the superannuation collection system for small business. By p
  • The self-employed – human rights, equity and fairness

    21-Nov Do the self-employed enjoy the same rights as workers and as others? Perhaps they are mo
  • Who pays for the ruling class to travel business class?

    26-Oct   “Attention please: Passengers in business class please take note there is a person dow
  • Make our roads safer, do not ever compromise safety

    20-Sep Small business in the transport sector under threat from union/big business cartels
  • COSBulletin for August – read it now!

    31-Aug The August edition of the COSBulletin is available - click
  • Will Australia be run by three unions and a handful of big businesses?

    10-Aug Will Australia be run by three unions and a handful of big businesses? To ensure we have
  • Congratulations to Senator Katy Gallagher on the Small Business role

    26-Jul COSBOA today congratulated Bill Shorten on the appointment of Senator Katy Gallagher Peter Strong C
  • Leaders to debate innovation at Vodafone National Small Business Summit

    04-Jul Leaders to debate innovation at Vodafone National Small Business Summit Who are the
  • Business Daily:Make Your Vote Count

    30-Jun COSBOA is quoted in an article on Business Daily on today,
  • Vodafone National Small Business Summit in the News

    23-Jun The 2016 Vodafone National Small Busi
  • Over 50% of weekend workers get less than award pay – and it’s legal

    31-May Over 50% of weekend workers get less than award pay - and it's legal (Breaking news - the
  • Marginal Seats and Small Business People – the facts

    20-May As can be seen by the table we have influence in this election.
  • Why we need big business to pay their bills on time

    12-May It is well known that cashflow is the king and queen,
  • COSBOA’s Pre-Budget Wish List…

    03-May COSBOA was invited to submit a
  • COSBOA Response to Superannuation Efficiency and Competitiveness Issues Paper

    29-Apr COSBOA lodged a response to the Superannuation Efficiency and Competitiveness Issues Paper today,
  • Can we resist the old has-beens and embrace real change

    15-Apr The new economy is different: oligopolies beware or begone Here is the
  • Some tax thoughts from some COSBOA members

    11-Apr Most of our members have their views on tax - tax collection,
  • The Velocity of Money – a chance for a simpler tax system?

     Here is an article by Phil Johns the COSBOA Treasurer and the CEO of the National Credit Providers A
  • The Fair Work System needs to be simple and in plain English

    30-Mar Proof that the Fair Work System needs to be simple and in plain English COSBOA not
  • Rod Sims re-appointment augers well for competition

    24-Mar COSBOA and its members are very pleased to see the re-appointment of Rod Sims as Chairman of the ACC
  • A Strong Government Creating Fair Competition

    16-Mar PRESS RELEASE COSBOA today congratulates the Government on their decision to ad
  • Australia is at a crossroads – jobs and living standards are under threat.

    09-Mar Australia is at a crossroads – jobs and living standards are under threat. In a
  • COSBOA Launches the COSbulletin!

    01-Mar COSBOA launched it's new newsletter the COSbulletin yesterday - check it out
  • When two, too big is so big they have no idea what’s happening- aka the Duopoly

    27-Feb Last year Coles admitted to unconscionable conduct against at least 250 companies.  This year Woolw
  • SMART COMPANY: Why unnaturally big is ALWAYS bad for business

    24-Feb Peter Strong's article on why Big Business is bad for business was published today by Smart Comp
  • COSBOA Pre Budget Submission Recommends Changes to Tax & Skills Systems

    17-Feb Council of Small Business of Australia (COSBOA) today released its Pre Budget Submission,
  • A Bellwether – is the government at the behest of big bullies like Wesfarmers?

    02-Feb Recently a group of business representatives met in Tamworth to discuss competition policy.  The me
  • 2016 to start off with a classic battle of big V small – Effects Test

    11-Jan The effects test (strengthening section 46 of the Competition legislation) is the first port of call
  • Have a great Christmas and a profitable healthy 2016

    24-Dec Thanks to everyone for the support in 2015 (you know who you are) and we'll keep the good fight goin
  • The Year that was 2015 – it was pretty good

    19-Dec There is no doubt 2015 was a year of outcomes for the small business people in Australia. In 2015 t
  • Long Service Leave for 3 hours work exceeds belief

    09-Nov There are moves afoot in Victoria to change the nature of long service leave from one of reward for
  • A Smart Petition that will have an Effect

    10-Sep You want competition?  Productivity? 
  • Treasury teamwork handles change better

    05-Aug Is there an emerging team culture in Treasury? There is no question that the last
  • Just for Fun – A Small Business Crossword

    28-Jul Take a break and stretch your mind with our Small Business Crossword! Click
  • Treasurer the Hon. Joe Hockey MP: Tax System needs to be Simplified for Small Business

    17-Jul Federal Treasurer the Hon. Joe Hockey MP addressed the Council of Small Business of Australia’s (C
  • Big Business wrong about section 46 of Harper’s Review

  • Australia Could Learn How to Support Small Business from Europe

     In the closing session of COSBOA’s Vodafone National Small Business Summit today (Thursday 16
  • Mental Health Advocate Awarded 2015 COSBOA Small Business Champion

     The founder of Billie Goat Soap,
  • BILLSON: “We’re on your side”

    15-Jul The Council of Small Business Australia (COSBOA) hosted its first ‘Summit Start Up Party’,
  • Superannuation Governance Changes Should Help Cut Costs for Business

    26-Jun COSBOA welcomes the announcement by Assistant Treasurer Josh Frydenberg for the tightening of govern
  • Small Business and the Nation’s Security

    13-Jun COSBOA: Small Businesses are the eyes and ears of our nation The Council of Small Business A
  • Defence Force reserves celebrate Small Business Supporters

    02-Jun COSBOA is very proud to support the Australian Defence Reserves. Our Chairman Paul Nielsen is on the
  • Response to Mark Latham’s rant about small business people.

    31-May Odd comments from a failed politician - a piece by Peter Strong CEO In the AFR of 30 May
  • Why Labor’s small business finance policy works for COSBOA

    26-May Here is a joint Blog from COSBOA's Chairman and CEO. Bill Shorten in his 2015 budget response propo
  • Netflix tax well and good, but it’s time to add GST to overseas purchases

    12-May  Why is Australia determined to protect offshore businesses at the expens
  • Budget extraordinaire shows respect for people in business

     COSBOA is impressed with a ground-breaking 2015 Federal Budget.  The budget inclusions for small bu
  • Our pre-Budget Newsletter

    11-May Please see our thoughts on the budget and other news
  • Good start to the budget count down for small business

    06-May COSBOA today congratulated the government and in particular Minister Bruce Billson on the announceme
  • Vodafone and COSBOA looking at increasing speed and lowering cost of communications

    05-May The Council of Small Business Australia (COSBOA) has announced Vodafone as its major sponsor for the
  • An Investment Allowance for small business will give the economy a good positive Kick

    30-Apr  The Council of Small Business of Australia and the
  • Accountants and bookkeepers will they only exist in science fiction?

    16-Apr Will accountants,
  • Where are we heading with competition policy?

    15-Apr When the report on Competition in Australia (the so called Harper Review) was released we found it 
  • Australian Human Rights Commission reaches out to business

    31-Mar Last week I attended an
  • Linchpins for small business people? There is a growing number.

     Recent positive and constructive announcements from the federal Small Business Minister Bruce Billso
  • Tax White Paper – start-up discussion on a needed process

    30-Mar Reform of the tax system? It is essential to undertake this activity as it is well overdue.  The go
  • We are flying with Flying Solo and their 74,000 micro businesses

    26-Mar COSBOA is pleased to announce that
  • Time for some proactive thinking about tax, employment, training and small business

    24-Mar COSBOA today released a paper that shows how innovative ideas can be used in tandem with traditional
  • Submission to Productivity Commission on Workplace Relations

    20-Mar Inquiry into the Workplace Relations Framework A response from the Council of Small Bus
  • After 40 years a change in contract fairness

     COSBOA congratulates Bruce Billson and the Abbot government on today’s announcement to extend lega
  • Small Business Champion still championing away

    10-Mar Below is a short comment we received from our current small business champion, Kathryn Bordonaro who
  • Tax – it’s all about getting ready for the future

     The Treasurer Joe Hockey recently
  • Renewable Energy Target will renew innovation – let’s do it.

    26-Feb Bruce Billson and Josh Frydenberg and others in this government are on the way to creating a brand n
  • Employer pays $10k for childcare then another $8.8k as punishment? Remove FBT on childcare and Gym membership.

    15-Feb Below is a copy of the media release,
  • Why we need newsagents and community pharmacy to exist

    11-Feb Coles and Woolworths (with the help of text book toting economists remote from reality) are always t
  • Grow and be healthy, Remove FBT on child care and health, make small business company tax 5%

    10-Feb Leading up to the small business package the government is working on as part of the next budget we
  • There is heat in the Workplace Relations Kitchen

    05-Feb The Productivity Commission has released the
  • Any Senate reform needs to be right for people not just big business

    13-Jan Article by Geoff Fader,
  • Unconscionable behaviour demonstrates need for cultural change

    22-Dec Big businesses that dominate a market place need to show responsibility otherwise people suffer and
  • We wish you a healthy wealthy and wise 2015

    20-Dec Thank you everyone for your support during the year.  In 2014,
  • Coles caught out and now plea bargaining

    17-Dec Finally after years of being ignored by the previous administration the ACCC now listens to the comm
  • Competition and productivity still compromised – We should embrace Minister Billson’s vision not engage in academic back tracking

    17-Nov  COSBOA has provided a response to the Draft Report of the Competition Policy Review 201

    11-Nov MEDIA RELEASE Issued by the Australian Booksellers Association (ABA) and Council of Small
  • Very happy to help regulators learn how to be regulated

    21-Oct For some time we at 
  • The integrity of the tax system

    17-Oct A post from Peter Strong Executive Officer COSBOA. Below is a message we received from a small bu
  • Generic branding kills productivity and innovation

  • Superannuation game changer

    09-Sep Changing the collection process for superannuation saves $billions,
  • Small Business Champion 2014 – Kathryn Bordonaro

    20-Aug Bravo Kathryn!  The bio of Kathryn is below.  The reason Kathryn is our small business champion is
  • We will lead the way, we’re working everyday – latest Song about Small Business people

    15-Aug After twelve months of watching our
  • The small business community has lost a champion – Vale Peter Judkins

    04-Aug The small business community is mourning the passing of one of its greatest supporters,
  • COSBOA commends B20 talks ahead of the NSBS

    23-Jul Small business is seen as the way forward and the key to a healthy world economy by all those who
  • COSBOA response to Competition Policy Review

    22-Jun COSBOA has always held the view that competition policy has failed the small business community.  S
  • What powers do we want for the National Small Business Commissioner?

     Below is our opening statement Please find the response from COSBOA to the Governments discussion p
  • Cost of doing Retail in Australia is about red tape and wages

     See our submission to the Productivity study into the costs of doing retail in Australia -
  • Board of Taxation Response

     GST is annoying and confusing and any FBT issues should rest with the individual who gets the benefi
  • Assessing the 2014 Federal Budget

    13-Jun Assessing budgets is different for small business than big,
  • National Small Business Summit – 7th & 8th August 2014 in Melbourne

    15-May Mark your diaries - It's on again, and it seems like yesterday we were gearing up for the 2013 Summi
  • What has COSBOA achieved? Has there been change?

    26-Apr Our achievements to March 2014   It is a good to sometimes stop and look at what has
  • COSBOA Supports War on Red Tape and Inefficient Compliance

    17-Mar The Council of Small Business of Australia (COSBOA) has congratulated the Federal Government on
  • COSBOA And The Association Specialists – Working together for the good of small business

    24-Jan COSBOA is pleased to announce the appointment of a small business The Association Specialists - to s
  • Commission of Audit Submission – Let’s make things simple.

    02-Jan Below is a copy of COSBOA's submission to the National Commission of Audit -  Summary
  • Review of 2013 – a year of flux

    24-Dec Summary (see full report
  • The height of hypocrisy? Must be the Duopoly.

    20-Dec An article by David Quilty Executive Director The Pharmacy Guild of Australia
  • A win for competition, innovation, the consumer and common sense

    10-Dec The limiting of discounts from Shopper Dockets to 4 cents is a win for competition. The duop
  • Small Business Task Forces Formed

    01-Dec COSBOA has formed various task forces to assist in policy assessment,
  • Duopoly is also a duopsony – that’s not good

    12-Nov Interestingly a little while ago Coles was pinged by the ACCC for claiming that their bread was made
  • Overregulation Threatens Small Business Lending – Terry Moody President of CAFBA

    27-Oct Don’t punish small business for the excesses of the derivatives market. The Council of Small Busi
  • Increasing productivity is a no brainer – or is it?

    10-Oct The Council of Small Business Australia (COSBOA) and Independent Senator for South Australia,
  • Confidence Comes with Certainty

    08-Sep Today we congratulated the Prime Minister elect, Tony Abbott, on his comprehensive election win.
  • Election 2013 Policy Comparison and Commentary

    01-Sep Small business people vote and there are over 2 million of us who provide jobs and incomes to alm
  • The words to the ‘Red Tape Nation’ Rap

    25-Aug Below are the words to the Rap
  • 2 million business people who employ around 5 million other people – important?

    20-Aug The Members of the Council of Small Business Organisations of Australia (COSBOA) know that the next
  • Article by John Strong on Complexity of Regulation for Small Business People

    19-Aug  The Society for Chaos Theory in Psychology & Life Sciences Newsletter Vol.20, No. 4
  • Tax Office talking to small business people through new site

    22-Jul The still newish Australian Tax Commissioner Chris Jordan will be at our
  • Not too late to have small business issues heard!

    09-Jul It’s not too late! There is still time to purchase tickets for our big event of the year – the N
  • Bureaucrats Continue to Ignore Small Business

    08-Jul from Real Estate Institute of Australia 16 Thesiger Court Deakin ACT 2600 Phone 02 6282 4277
  • In the election the small business people will decide the western suburbs of Sydney

    02-Jul The western suburbs of Sydney are a hot bed of self employed people.  There are some 150,
  • The big retail landlords are very different from the smaller landlords – very

    01-Jul Big landlords are very different from other landlords – very   Over many years the Council
  • Can we regulate the regulators? Complete the survey and tell’em!

     Now is the opportunity to get information to the Productivity Commission, and through them the gover